Back to Book List
To Kill a Mockingbird
Part Two
Chapter 20
Chapter Summary
In this pivotal chapter, Atticus Finch delivers his closing argument during the trial of Tom Robinson, who has been unjustly accused of raping Mayella Ewell. The courtroom is tense, filled with a mix of townspeople eager to hear the verdict. Scout and Jem sit in the balcony, anxiously awaiting the outcome, aware that their father's reputation and moral integrity are on the line.
Atticus begins his argument by emphasizing the legal principle of reasonable doubt, urging the jury to look past their ingrained racial biases. He articulates the importance of justice and the law, reminding the jurors that their duty is to uphold fairness. Atticus highlights the lack of concrete evidence against Tom Robinson, pointing out the inconsistencies in the testimonies of the prosecution witnesses, particularly Mayella and her father, Bob Ewell.
Throughout his speech, Atticus paints a vivid picture of the events leading to the alleged crime, explaining that Mayella was a victim of her circumstances—trapped in a life of poverty and abuse. He argues that Bob Ewell's motivation for accusing Tom Robinson stems from his own shame and guilt for failing to provide for his family, rather than any actual wrongdoing by Tom.
Atticus's rhetoric appeals to the jury's sense of morality, insisting that they must not let racial prejudice cloud their judgment. He challenges them to consider whether a man like Tom, who is physically disabled and unable to commit the crime as described, could have attacked Mayella. His argument is not just a defense of Tom, but an indictment of the societal norms that allow racism to permeate justice.
As Atticus concludes, he makes a poignant plea, reminding the jury that in the eyes of the law, all men are created equal. He implores them to do what is right and just, despite the pressures of their community that may push them toward a different conclusion. The weight of his words hangs in the air as the courtroom listens intently, illustrating the moral complexity of the situation.
Atticus's closing argument serves as a crucial moment in the novel, showcasing his deep commitment to justice and equality. It also marks a turning point for Scout and Jem, who begin to grasp the profound injustices of their society. The chapter encapsulates the core themes of the novel: the struggle against prejudice, the quest for truth, and the moral dilemmas faced in the pursuit of justice.